Controversy continues surrounding Rep. Carnavale’s residency

July 27, 2016 8:14 pm

There were two dead–locked votes from the two member Providence Board of Canvassers on Wednesday as they prepare to make a decision ultimately deciding whether or not Rep. John Carnevale is eligible to run for re–election in his current Providence State Rep. seat.

This meeting comes amid claims that Rep. Carnevale may actually live in Johnston. As the controversy wages forward, he says he’s not backing out of the race.

"No plans at all," said Carnevale. "I will have no other comments until after a verdict has been rendered tomorrow."

The controversial rulings on Wednesday had to do with GOP Chair Brandon Bell’s request for further documents pertaining to Carnevale’s residency and testimony from a Providence police officer who says the Rep. asked to be ticketed outside of the home where he claims to live in Providence right before a July hearing.

The Board of Canvassers Chair, Claudia Haugen, a Democrat, defended her decision after the meeting, saying it is in no way political.

"I feel as though there would be enough information to make a decision it’s very difficult. We have two board members and you can’t expect everybody to agree on things," said Haugen.

Carnavale’s lawyer pleased with the decision, while Bell is outraged.

"I don’t think she was reluctant I think she followed the statute…this is simply a fishing expedition to see what people might say and delve into personal background,” said State Rep. Robert Jacquard, Carnevale’s attorney.

"I can’t believe it I think it’s absolutely ridiculous. The statute gives broad authority to the board of canvassers and she had her mind made up before she walked into that room,” said Bell.

Mayor Elorza was quick to issue the following statement:

“I am deeply disappointed with the Chairwoman’s decision to ignore the advice of the City Solicitor’s office and refuse to consider additional evidence about Mr. Carnevale’s voter eligibility.

The public deserves a thorough and comprehensive review of the evidence including information that has come to light since the challenge was filed.

The Chairwoman should reconsider her position and hear this evidence before the Board makes its decision.

I am instructing Lt. Richard Fernandes of the Providence Police Department, Public Safety Commissioner Paré, Director of Human Resources Sybil Bailey, and Benefits Specialist Jennifer Wein to attend tomorrow’s meeting prepared to answer questions.”

The next Board of Canvassers meeting is Thursday. We are told six people have been subpoenaed to appear. A vote is expected.